Thứ Tư, 25 tháng 4, 2012

Entry 4_TA THI THANH HOA

ENTRY 4
Argument structure and Fallacies


Item1:

You should never gamble. Once you start gambling you find it hard to stop. Soon you are spending all your money on gambling, and eventually you will turn to crime to support your earnings.

Analysis:
Once you start gampling you
---> You find hard to stop (hidden premise: you become addicted to gambling)
---> you spending all money on gambling (hidden premise: you need lots of money)
----> you will turn to crime to support your earnings

è Fallacy of  slipery slope


Item 2:

Bill: "I believe that abortion is morally wrong." 

Dave: "Of course you would say that, you're a priest." 
Bill: "What about the arguments I gave to support my position?" 
Dave: "Those don't count. Like I said, you're a priest, so you have to say that abortion is wrong. Further, you are just a lackey to the Pope, so I can't believe what you say."



Analysis:
structure of argument: You’re a priest -> you have to say that abortion is wrong
                                     You just a lackey to the Pope
                                     -----------------------------------------------------
                                      Abortion is not wrong 

  ---> weak, invalid argument
      è  Personal attack


Etem3:


Analysis:
2 =  A number ( x=y)
1 =  A number (z=y)
2=1 (x=z)

    invalid conclusion
è Fallacy of presumption

entry 4- ta thi phuong


Entry 4: Tạ Thị Phương-E14
Item 1: 


Content Fallacies (False dilemma):
"rose_ flower" said: "mà không học được thì ở nhà lấy chồng chứ biết làm gì hả anh?"
In fact, not being able to further her study, the person whose nickname is “rose_flower” has many choices such as starting her own business, for say.



Item 2: video “Trà Vfresh Atiso”
Link download:   http://video.zing.vn/video/clip/Tra-Vfresh-Atiso---Minh-nhe-nhu-long-hong-Siu-Black.237390.html

Structural fallacies:
If you drink “Atiso” tea, you feel as light as a feather comfortably.
If              A            then             B
(You want)  to feel as light as a feather comfortably.
                                B
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



                  You should drink “Atiso” tea.
                                                   A
Analysis:
This argument is invalid

Item 3: quotation
I hate mankind, for I think myself one of the best of them, and I know how bad I am.
(Joseph Baretti, quoted in Boswell’s Life of Samuel Johnson)

Content fallacies (hasty generalization):
this is a form of fallacies of presumption.


I am one of the best of mankind
I am bad
------------------------------------------------------
therefore: the whole mankind is bad

Joseph assumes that the whole mankind is bad because he is one of them and he is bad: what is true for one member is true for the whole group (false premise)




Entry4_nguyenthihuong


Entry 4_Nguyễn Thị Hương

ITEM 1: Truyện cười: Suy luận lôgic


Sau khi đến hiện trường, cảnh sát hình sự viết báo cáo điều tra:
"Tối qua, tại trung tâm thành phố, một tiệm thuốc tây đã bị vét sạch, chỉ còn lại thuốc ngừa thai và dầu gội đầu. Kết luận: Thủ phạm là một người đàn ông trên 70 tuổi và bị hói".

-          Analysis: Content fallacy-Hasty generalization
Men are bald and over 70 years old, they cannot use pills and shampoo
Stores are stolen all drugs, but pills and shampoo
Therefore, the culprit is a bald and over 70 year-old man
False premises: bald and over 70 year-old men can still take birth control pills and shampoo (they can give to others to use ....). Conclusion was made in haste


ITEM 2: Truyện cười: Logic học

Trong tiết logic học, giáo sư nói sinh viên:

- Ví dụ nhé, nhà em nuôi có con bò nào không?

- Có ạ...

- Vậy theo logic, nhà em có một đồng cỏ, đúng không nào?

- Đúng ạ!

- Vẫn theo logic, em có một căn nhà bên đồng cỏ?

- Ôi, đúng ạ!

- Vì em có ngôi nhà tuyệt thế, chắc là em sẽ có tiền rủng rỉnh đôi chút?

- Dĩ nhiên thưa thầy!

- Và vì thế, theo logic em sẽ có bạn gái?

- Thật tuyệt, chính xác thế...

- Và vì em có bạn gái, suy ra em không phải dân đồng tính luyến ái...! Đó là logic!

Quá thích về môn logic này, chàng sinh viên chạy đi tìm bạn để khoe:

- Này, nhà mày có con bò nào không?

- Không!

- Theo logic... vậy có lẽ là mày bị đồng tính luyến ái!

- ??!

-          Source: http://cuoi.xitrum.net/hocsinh/2112.html

-          Analysis: slippery slope
If you have cows,
Then you have a pasture (hidden premise: all cows eat grass)
Then you have a house near the pasture (most house is near farm)
Then you have a lot of money (most people have a house with a farm are rich)
Then you have a girlfriend (most girls like boys who have much money)
Then you are not gay ( most gays don’t like a girl)
àInsufficient premies leading to false premises

ITEM 3: A CLIP

-         Analysis : content fallacies – Fallacies of relevance
It appeal to Tradition -  Trying to get someone to prefer Heineken because it still maintains its taste for a long time




 


Entry 4 – Nguyen Ngoc Tram
CRITICAL THINKING
        ARGUMENT
Item 1:
 
Source: http://www.cracked.com/funny-1314-logical-fallacy/
       Analysis: irrelevant conclusion
_ An argument provides poor reasoning in support of its conclusion.
_A: “I can conceive of a perfect being, called god”
  B: “One of the attributes of perfection is existence” (is irrelevant information)
→ God exists. (is irrelevant conclusion)
_If according to one of the nature of perfect is existence, we can not confirm that god exist.


Item 2:
Dũng cảm và mưu trí
Chàng hỏi nàng: "Em có đồng ý lấy anh không?"
- Không ! Chồng em phải là người vừa dũng cảm vừa mưu trí.
- Nhưng anh đã từng cứu em khỏi chết đuối ở hồ mà?
- Hành động đó dũng cảm đấy, nhưng chưa đủ nói lên mưu trí của anh.
- Thế em có biết ai đã nghĩ ra cách làm cho thuyền chìm không?
- !!!!!
          Analysis: hasty generalization
_The man base on his own opinion about how is a wise guy. As for him, smart guy is someone who can get what he wants despite the consequences and he does it in the wrong way that the girl do not want. In specific, the man in this situation just cares about his own business, he does not think about the consequences like: If he could not save the girl in time, the girl could have died.
_His opinion about smart guy is not true and can not represent for all smart people will do something like that.

Item 3:
Bill: "I like classical music and I think it is of higher quality than most modern music."
Jill: "That stuff is for old people."
Dave: "Yeah, only real woosies listen to that crap. Besides, Anthrax rules! It Rules!"
Bill: "Well, I don't really like it that much. Anthrax is much better."
Analysis: Peer Pressure
_ Bill likes classical music. However, Bill’s friends think only girly kind of man or old people listen to that kind of music.
_ It is obviously that Bill’s friends do not like classical music so they talk to persuade him.  Bill is under his friend pressure and changes his opinion.
_The influence exerted by a peer group, encouraging individuals to change their attitudes, values, or behaviors in order to conform to group norms.
`